← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

delete PART 671—RAIL TRANSIT ROADWAY WORKER PROTECTION 49-CFR-671 · 2024
Summary

Federal regulation mandating comprehensive Roadway Worker Protection programs for rail transit agencies receiving federal funds, requiring detailed safety manuals, training, job briefings, redundant protections, and state oversight to protect workers accessing track areas.

Reason

Imposes heavy compliance costs through prescriptive mandates, diverting resources from transit services to paperwork. Duplicates existing safety incentives from unions, tort liability, and state oversight. Creates one-size-fits-all federal overreach that stifles local innovation and flexibility. Unseen costs include bureaucratic expansion, checklist mentality over genuine safety, and reduced resources for actual service improvements.

delete PART 596—AUTOMATIC EMERGENCY BRAKING TEST DEVICES 49-CFR-596 · 2024
Summary

Specifies precise technical requirements for test devices (pedestrian/vehicle mannequins and carriers) used in compliance testing of automatic emergency braking systems. Incorporates ISO standards and defines dimensions, visual properties, radar reflectivity, and measurement protocols to ensure consistent, reproducible test results.

Reason

Technical testing specifications should be determined by industry standards bodies, market competition, or state-level requirements—not the federal government. This rule adds $185,000+ pages of complexity while imposing unnecessary uniformity that stifles innovation in testing methodologies. The regulation itself does nothing to improve safety; it merely prescribes one approved method, creating a barrier to alternative approaches that might be more effective or efficient. Private labs and automakers have strong incentives to develop reliable testing protocols without federal micromanagement, and any legitimate need for standardization can be met through voluntary consensus standards.

delete PART 561—DOCUMENTATION FOR ELECTRIC-POWERED VEHICLES 49-CFR-561 · 2024
Summary

Mandates electric vehicle manufacturers to submit standardized emergency response guides (ERGs) and rescue sheets to NHTSA, plus extensive technical documentation on battery safety systems, warning systems, and thermal runaway mitigation upon request. Applies to vehicles with electrical systems over 60VDC/30VAC, with phased compliance dates and exemptions for small-volume manufacturers.

Reason

Compliance imposes significant hidden costs passed to consumers, creating barriers for smaller EV manufacturers despite exemptions. Emergency responder safety information is already available through voluntary ISO standards (17840 series) and market incentives—manufacturers have strong liability and reputational incentives to provide accurate rescue information without federal mandate. The technical documentation requirements are burdensome paperwork that distracts from actual innovation and assumes federal centralization is necessary, violating federalism principles. First responders and consumers would be no less safe if manufacturers voluntarily adopted the ISO standards and maintained records for their own liability protection.

delete PART 523—VEHICLE CLASSIFICATION 49-CFR-523 · 2024
Summary

This regulation defines vehicle categories and technical terms to determine which vehicles are subject to Title V of the Motor Vehicle Information and Cost Savings Act. It classifies vehicles by weight (GVWR classes), functionality (ambulance, bus, truck), and design features (approach angle, clearance), establishing a taxonomy for regulatory coverage.

Reason

The classification system imposes hidden costs: manufacturers must expend resources on correct categorization, distort vehicle designs to fit favorable categories, and enables broader regulatory burdens that increase compliance expenses, disadvantage small businesses, and exceed proper federal authority. Even purely definitional regulations expand the administrative state and create complexity that ultimately harms consumers through higher prices and reduced innovation.

delete PART 513—WHISTLEBLOWER PROGRAM 49-CFR-513 · 2024
Summary

Establishes a whistleblower bounty program for NHTSA enforcement actions. Provides 10-30% awards from collected monetary sanctions exceeding $1M for original information about safety violations, with procedures for submission, confidentiality, and eligibility.

Reason

Creates perverse incentives that distort employee behavior and undermine internal corporate reporting channels. Adds bureaucratic overhead to an already bloated regulatory state. Redundant with tort law and existing criminal enforcement. The bounty system encourages 'regulation entrepreneurship' over productive work and exposes trade secrets.

delete PART 369—REPORTS OF MOTOR CARRIERS 49-CFR-369 · 2024
Summary

This regulation mandates annual reporting (Form M for property carriers, Form MP-1 for passenger carriers) for motor carriers based on revenue thresholds. It establishes classification systems (Class I/II/III) using inflation-adjusted revenue limits, requires reporting by March 31, and provides mechanisms for exemptions from filing and confidentiality protections. The rule governs data collection on operating revenues, accounting periods, and public release of information.

Reason

This reporting mandate imposes significant compliance costs on thousands of businesses—especially small carriers, where per-employee costs are 30% higher—for data collection that FMCSA could obtain through less burdensome means (random sampling, audits, voluntary reporting). The regulation creates a hidden tax consuming time and resources without clear justification that its benefits outweigh these unseen costs. It exemplifies regulatory overreach: government demanding routine reports from private enterprise as a matter of course, rather than targeting enforcement based on actual safety concerns. Eliminating this universal reporting requirement would reduce the regulatory burden while allowing FMCSA to focus on high-risk carriers through complaint-driven or risk-based oversight consistent with limited government principles.

delete PART 246—CERTIFICATION OF SIGNAL EMPLOYEES 49-CFR-246 · 2024
Summary

The regulation establishes minimum federal safety certification standards for railroad signal employees, requiring railroads to implement written programs for training, testing, and monitoring, with FRA approval.

Reason

This regulation imposes significant compliance costs, especially on small railroads, and creates barriers to entry. Federal oversight of signal employee certification represents unnecessary centralization; market incentives, liability, and industry standards already ensure safety. Adding to the regulatory burden contributes to the opaque Code of Federal Regulations that undermines the rule of law.

delete PART 245—QUALIFICATION AND CERTIFICATION OF DISPATCHERS 49-CFR-245 · 2024
Summary

Federal Railroad Administration rule establishing mandatory certification requirements for railroad dispatchers, including training, testing, medical standards, drug/alcohol screening, and ongoing monitoring. Applies to most railroads with exemptions for plant, tourist, and disconnected rapid transit operations.

Reason

Imposes significant hidden costs on railroads totaling billions nationwide, disproportionately burdens small operators (30% higher compliance costs per employee), federalizes what should be state/private functions, and creates barriers to entry through rigid bureaucratic certification. Market forces, liability exposure, and private certification already provide strong safety incentives more efficiently than one-size-fits-all federal mandates.

delete PART 24—UNIFORM RELOCATION ASSISTANCE AND REAL PROPERTY ACQUISITION FOR FEDERAL AND FEDERALLY ASSISTED PROGRAMS 49-CFR-24 · 2024
Summary

Implements the Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act, requiring federal agencies and recipients of federal financial assistance to provide uniform relocation assistance, fair housing standards, and specific compensation to property owners and displaced persons when real property is acquired or displaced for federal/federally-assisted projects. Establishes detailed definitions, eligibility criteria, and procedures for relocation payments, comparable replacement housing, and advisory services.

Reason

Federalizes what should be state and local matters, imposing massive administrative burdens ($14,000 per household in hidden compliance costs) on infrastructure projects. Creates perverse incentives: agencies may delay or avoid beneficial projects due to relocation mandates, artificially inflates project costs through required payments, and distorts housing markets by mandating 'comparable' replacement rather than allowing market solutions. The regulation's 'one-size-fits-all' approach violates constitutional federalism—property acquisition and eminent domain are traditional state functions; federal conditioning of funds on compliance commandeers state resources. Compliance complexity exceeds 185,000 pages of regulations, undermining rule of law. Unseen consequences: reduced housing supply, higher infrastructure costs passed to taxpayers, barriers to economic development, and dependency on government assistance rather than private negotiation. States/localities can craft superior, tailored solutions without federal bureaucracy.

delete PART 2952—SOLICITATION PROVISIONS AND CONTRACT CLAUSES 48-CFR-2952 · 2024
Summary

This regulation comprises multiple mandatory clauses for Department of Labor contracts, governing Contracting Officer's Representative (COR) authority, federal records management, data breach response, organizational conflicts of interest, IPv6 technical compliance, incremental funding, electronic invoicing, and essential services contingency planning. The clauses impose extensive compliance obligations on contractors including strict record-keeping, encryption, incident reporting within one hour, mandatory training, off-site contingency planning, and technical standards.

Reason

The regulation imposes massive, one-size-fits-all compliance costs on all contractors regardless of contract size or risk profile. Small businesses face disproportionate burdens (nearly 30% higher per-employee costs), creating barriers to entry and protecting incumbents. Requirements like 1-hour breach reporting, mandatory contingency plans, and technical standards inflate costs with unclear marginal benefit over tailored contracts. The labyrinthine rules (185,000+ pages of CFR) violate rule of law by being impossible to fully comprehend, while enabling regulatory capture through complex requirements that favor large firms with dedicated compliance departments. These unseen costs dwarf any efficiency gains.

keep PART 2945—GOVERNMENT PROPERTY 48-CFR-2945 · 2024
Summary

Requires contracting officers to insert two mandatory clauses in government contracts: one requiring contractors to report theft of government property, and another establishing asset reporting requirements for high-value government assets.

Reason

The regulation serves a legitimate, narrow government interest in protecting taxpayer assets with minimal compliance burden. Standardized clauses reduce transaction costs and ensure uniform accountability across all federal contracts. Deleting it would create asset tracking gaps and increase fraud/waste, with no better alternative for centralizing these basic protections.

keep PART 2943—CONTRACT MODIFICATIONS 48-CFR-2943 · 2024
Summary

Requires contractors to notify the contracting officer of any requests to change contract scope in all DOL solicitations and contracts.

Reason

Americans would be worse off without it: unauthorized scope changes could lead to significant waste of taxpayer funds and fraud. The minimal notification requirement is essential oversight that prevents cost overruns and maintains procurement integrity. The compliance burden is negligible compared to the risk of unapproved work slipping through.

delete PART 2942—CONTRACT ADMINISTRATION AND AUDIT SERVICES 48-CFR-2942 · 2024
Summary

This DOL acquisition regulation mandates that contracting officers include two clauses in all relevant contracts: one ensuring government access to contractor systems that handle federal information, and another requiring mandatory training for contractor employees, applying to all service contracts including construction.

Reason

Adds to the regulatory burden with compliance costs that disproportionately harm small businesses; mandatory clauses reduce contractual flexibility and can be achieved through negotiated terms. Unseen effects include increased administrative overhead, potential barriers to entry for new contractors, and costs ultimately borne by taxpayers.

keep PART 2939—ACQUISITION OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 48-CFR-2939 · 2024
Summary

Requires DOL contracting officers to include a Section 508 compliance clause in all information and communication technology (ICT) contracts, ensuring that technology acquired by DOL meets accessibility standards for people with disabilities.

Reason

Deletion could deny disabled citizens equal access to DOL services. The mandatory clause ensures reliable enforcement of civil rights requirements that voluntary procurement policies might neglect, and its removal would directly harm vulnerable Americans.

delete PART 2937—SERVICE CONTRACTING 48-CFR-2937 · 2024
Summary

Mandates inclusion of a specific clause requiring contractors to maintain emergency continuity plans for essential services in federal contracts supporting agency continuity operations.

Reason

This regulation imposes unnecessary compliance costs on federal contractors, particularly small businesses that bear 30% higher per-employee costs, adding to the $2 trillion annual regulatory burden and the $14,000+ hidden tax per household. It exemplifies bureaucratic mission creep—creating barriers to entry, distorting market incentives, and federalizing what agencies could handle through flexible guidance without a one-size-fits-all mandate.