← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

delete PART 50—PROCEDURES FOR REESTABLISHING A FORMAL GOVERNMENT-TO-GOVERNMENT RELATIONSHIP WITH THE NATIVE HAWAIIAN COMMUNITY 43-CFR-50 · 2016
Summary

This regulation establishes the process for the Department of Interior to reestablish a formal government-to-government relationship with a Native Hawaiian governing entity. It sets requirements for drafting a governing document, verifying membership, conducting ratification referendums and elections, and includes numerical thresholds for approval. Once recognized, the entity receives the same federal relationship as recognized Indian tribes but is excluded from federal Indian programs unless Congress specifically provides eligibility.

Reason

This regulation violates constitutional federalism by federalizing a matter reserved to states under the Tenth Amendment. It expands the administrative state, creates special privileges for an ethnic-based government, and establishes a new layer of bureaucracy with unlimited potential for rent-seeking. The vague membership definitions invite abuse while imposing substantial compliance costs on both the Native Hawaiian community and taxpayers.

delete PART 48—AMENDMENTS TO THE HAWAIIAN HOMES COMMISSION ACT 43-CFR-48 · 2016
Summary

Provides federal review process for Hawaii's amendments to the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act, requiring Secretary of the Interior to determine if congressional approval is needed based on criteria affecting trust benefits, funds, and beneficiary qualifications.

Reason

Violates Tenth Amendment federalism; Hawaii as a state should control its own land and trust programs without federal bureaucratic gatekeeping. The Secretary's review adds costs and delays with no compelling federal interest. If federal interests exist, Congress should directly legislate conditions, not delegate to an unelected agency. The entire process is unconstitutional overreach.

delete PART 47—LAND EXCHANGE PROCEDURES 43-CFR-47 · 2016
Summary

This federal regulation establishes detailed procedures for exchanging Hawaiian Home Lands held in trust for native Hawaiians under the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act. It requires Secretary of the Interior approval for all exchanges, mandates equal or greater land value via federal appraisal standards, imposes extensive documentation and consultation requirements with beneficiaries, and creates a 120-day review process. The regulation applies exclusively to a race-based land entitlement program.

Reason

This regulation enforces federal overreach into state-administered land use, perpetuates a constitutionally suspect race-based entitlement system, and imposes costly bureaucratic procedures that restrict property rights and market efficiency. The federal trust relationship lacks valid constitutional basis and should be devolved to Hawaii with race-neutral administration, eliminating these compliance burdens and restoring full property alienability.

keep PART 16—CONSERVATION OF HELIUM 43-CFR-16 · 2016
Summary

The regulation authorizes the Secretary to enter into helium disposition agreements with qualified applicants to conserve helium that would otherwise be wasted during oil and gas production on federal lands. It outlines application requirements, prohibits wells primarily for helium without permission, ensures existing rights are protected, mandates royalties or compensation to secure U.S. return on value, allows renegotiation clauses, and requires performance bonds.

Reason

Deletion would waste helium that is essential for medical imaging, scientific research, and high-tech manufacturing, increasing costs and supply constraints. The regulation efficiently achieves conservation and fair compensation through a structured framework that balances private incentives with public interest—coordinating helium extraction with existing oil/gas operations and protecting lessees' rights in a way that ad hoc or purely market solutions could not reliably ensure due to the complexities of federal land use and mixed-resource extraction.

delete PART 88—WORLD TRADE CENTER HEALTH PROGRAM 42-CFR-88 · 2016
Summary

Establishes the WTC Health Program to provide medical monitoring and treatment benefits for 9/11 responders (firefighters, police, cleanup workers) and survivors (residents, workers, students in affected NYC areas). Defines eligibility criteria based on presence, time worked, and exposure; creates Clinical Centers of Excellence, Data Centers, and a Nationwide Provider Network; sets application, certification, and appeals procedures.

Reason

Creates a federal healthcare entitlement program violating limited government principles. Healthcare is not an enumerated federal power; this expands bureaucratic control, distorts medical markets, imposes administrative costs, and sets precedent for further federalization. Private insurance, charitable foundations, and state/local programs can address legitimate 9/11-related health needs more efficiently without constitutional overreach or dependency creation.

delete PART 34—MEDICAL EXAMINATION OF ALIENS 42-CFR-34 · 2016
Summary

This regulation mandates comprehensive medical examinations for aliens seeking visas, admission, or adjustment of status. It requires screening for specific communicable diseases, vaccine-preventable diseases, mental/physical disorders posing threats, and drug abuse. The CDC determines which diseases qualify as 'of public health significance' and may require additional testing based on epidemiological factors. Medical examiners issue Class A (inadmissible) or Class B (potentially inadmissible) notifications based on findings, with an appeals process available.

Reason

The regulation imposes substantial compliance costs, privacy intrusions, and bureaucratic overhead to screen immigrants for health conditions that often pose no actual threat. Its vague standards—'threat to property, safety, or welfare,' 'serious in degree or permanent'—grant CDC and medical examiners sweeping discretion to exclude individuals based on subjective judgments, enabling discriminatory outcomes. Vaccination mandates coerce medical procedures, while the expansive 'public health significance' definition permits unilateral disease list expansions without congressional oversight. These unseen costs—delayed immigration, lost talent, stigmatization of illness, and erosion of equal protection—far outweigh any marginal benefit, especially given that targeted quarantine powers could address genuine contagious disease threats without a blanket surveillance regime.

delete PART 11—CLINICAL TRIALS REGISTRATION AND RESULTS INFORMATION SUBMISSION 42-CFR-11 · 2016
Summary

Mandates electronic submission of comprehensive clinical trial data to ClinicalTrials.gov for applicable drug and device studies, requiring registration before enrollment and results reporting after completion, with ongoing updates.

Reason

Delete to avoid compliance costs that drain research resources, disproportionately harm small innovators, and create barriers to entry. The mandate supplants efficient market-driven transparency (journal policies, reputational incentives) with a one-size-fits-all bureaucracy prone to capture and mission creep. Unseen effects include discouraged research, delayed trials, and regulatory ossification that stifles medical innovation.

delete PART 109-1—INTRODUCTION 41-CFR-109 · 2016
Summary

DOE Property Management Regulations establish detailed internal procedures for managing personal property (equipment, supplies) including tracking, inventory, loans, disposal, loss reporting, and control requirements for DOE operations and designated contractors.

Reason

This internal bureaucratic rule imposes significant compliance costs on DOE and contractors with no public benefit. Property management should be handled through agency guidance or commercial practices, not federal regulation. The detailed record-keeping, inventory mandates, and approval processes represent the exact type of hidden tax and administrative burden that stifles efficiency without serving any constitutional or compelling public purpose.

delete PART 1037—CONTROL OF EMISSIONS FROM NEW HEAVY-DUTY MOTOR VEHICLES 40-CFR-1037 · 2016
Summary

This EPA regulation sets emissions standards (criteria pollutants and greenhouse gases) for new heavy-duty vehicles, with phase-in schedules, testing requirements, and credit-trading programs. It applies to manufacturers but impacts the entire heavy-duty trucking industry through compliance costs and technical mandates.

Reason

The rule imposes massive compliance costs that inflate truck prices, disproportionately harming small trucking firms and raising goods costs for all Americans. It represents federal overreach into what should be state or market-managed domains, creates barriers to entry protecting incumbent manufacturers, and risks perverse outcomes—such as prolonging the life of older, dirtier fleets—due to elevated new vehicle prices. A market-based approach (e.g., carbon tax) would achieve environmental aims more efficiently with far less economic distortion and bureaucratic complexity.

delete PART 770—FORMALDEHYDE STANDARDS FOR COMPOSITE WOOD PRODUCTS 40-CFR-770 · 2016
Summary

EPA formaldehyde emission standards for composite wood products requiring third-party certification, testing, and recordkeeping under TSCA Title VI.

Reason

Imposes high compliance costs that disproportionately burden small businesses and raise consumer prices. Federalizes what states or industry standards could handle more efficiently, creates rigid barriers to innovation, and invites regulatory capture. Market-based disclosure or state-level standards would achieve similar health protection at far lower cost.

keep PART 749—WATER TREATMENT CHEMICALS 40-CFR-749 · 2016
Summary

Regulation under TSCA prohibits distribution and use of hexavalent chromium-based water treatment chemicals in comfort cooling towers (HVAC systems) due to cancer risk from air emissions, while allowing industrial uses. Requires labeling, recordkeeping, and reporting from distributors.

Reason

Without this ban, Americans face increased cancer risk from inhaling hexavalent chromium emissions from cooling towers in populated buildings. The prohibition prevents harm proactively; alternatives like tort law are retrospective and inadequate for carcinogens with long latency, while state-by-state regulation would create dangerous patchwork protection.

delete PART 747—METALWORKING FLUIDS 40-CFR-747 · 2016
Summary

EPA bans adding nitrosating agents to four specific chemicals in metalworking fluids due to cancer risk, and requires distributors to send prescribed warning letters and affix labels with exact wording and type sizes.

Reason

Compliance costs and contribution to the unmanageable CFR accumulation outweigh marginal safety benefits; tort liability and industry standards can more efficiently address carcinogen risks without federal micromanagement of niche substances.

delete PART 202—MOTOR CARRIERS ENGAGED IN INTERSTATE COMMERCE 40-CFR-202 · 2016
Summary

Federal regulation setting maximum noise emission standards for commercial motor vehicles (over 10,000 lbs GVWR/GCWR) in interstate commerce. Establishes dB(A) limits measured at 50 feet under various conditions: 86/90 dB(A) for pre-1986 vehicles and 83/87 dB(A) for 1986+ vehicles on highways; 88/85 dB(A) for stationary engine tests. Requires mufflers, prohibits exhaust bypasses, and regulates tire tread patterns.

Reason

Imposes significant hidden compliance costs on motor carriers—especially small businesses—for a localized nuisance better addressed by states via tort law, zoning, or their own standards. Federal overreach violates Tenth Amendment, creates barriers to entry, and locks in obsolete 1975-era technology standards. The economic burden (higher shipping costs, reduced competition) outweighs marginal noise reduction benefits, representing classic regulatory unintended consequences.

keep PART 3012—EX PARTE COMMUNICATIONS 39-CFR-3012 · 2016
Summary

These are procedural rules governing ex parte communications (out-ofrecord communications with decision-makers) in Postal Regulatory Commission proceedings. They define scope, prohibited communications, reporting requirements, and penalties to ensure transparency and fairness in the regulatory decision-making process.

Reason

Without these rules, secret backroom communications between Postal Service, powerful stakeholders, and decision-makers would distort the regulatory process, enabling regulatory capture and undermining fairness. The minimal compliance burden is essential to maintain equal access, prevent corruption, and preserve the rule of law in proceedings that affect postal rates and services impacting all Americans and businesses.

keep PART 912—PROCEDURES TO ADJUDICATE CLAIMS FOR PERSONAL INJURY OR PROPERTY DAMAGE ARISING OUT OF THE OPERATION OF THE U.S. POSTAL SERVICE 39-CFR-912 · 2016
Summary

Procedures for filing, processing, and settling tort claims against the U.S. Postal Service under the Federal Tort Claims Act, including claim requirements, evidentiary standards, limitations periods, and review processes.

Reason

Provides accessible, standardized process for citizen redress, ensuring due process and consistent treatment. Deleting would create uncertainty and arbitrary denial of legitimate claims without offsetting cost savings.